Daniel 2: When is the Coming of Christ?
Responding to the Christadelphian View
Introduction
Daniel 2 is a Christadelphian favourite. A Christadelphian essential. When all else fails, this chapter is sent in to bat, bearing the weight of an exceptionally clunky eschatological framework which teaches something like this:
- There were several successive empires from Babylon to Rome
(This is the gold, silver, bronze, and iron) - Christ entered the scene in the first century
(This somehow didn’t make it into the prophecy) - The church was established
(This also, for some reason, didn’t make it into the vision) - The church lost the faith entirely as soon as the apostles left
(Also missing from the prophecy) - Rome disintegrated into the various mixed nations of Europe.
(This is the iron mixed with clay) - John Thomas finally rediscovered the faith: hello, Christadelphianism!
(Again—missing from the prophecy) - Christ will return and destroy the rogue empires of men
(This is the stone striking the statue) - His kingdom, a political dominion like all others, will instantly conquer the earth
(This is the stone becoming a mountain that fills the earth)
Once a few basic truths are established, Daniel 2 ceases to be a Christadelphian ally. To the contrary, it establishes the impossibility of Christadelphian eschatology beyond any reasonable doubt. If the following article does not do this you are welcome to tell me so. Contact me at the bottom of this page.
Remember, however, that proof is moral obligation. If I can prove my case, you must believe it.
The Basics of Daniel 2
In a dream, Nebuchadnezzar sees an image of many metals representing successive empires of history—Babylon (Gold), Medo-Persia (Silver), Greece (Bronze), and Rome (Iron). The text only lists these four kingdoms, despite a fifth material being introduced: clay. When the clay is introduced, the text does not describe it as a fifth kingdom in addition to the others, but as the fourth being divided and mixed with other people:
“Then there will be a fourth kingdom as strong as iron… Now in that you saw the feet and toes, partly of potter’s clay and partly of iron; it will be a divided kingdom; but it will have in it the toughness of iron, inasmuch as you saw the iron mixed with common clay” (Daniel 2:40-41 LSB, emphasis added).
Despite considerable dispute over the identity of the clay, the Old Testament is clear:
“‘Can I not, O house of Israel, deal with you as this potter does?’ declares Yahweh. ‘Behold, like the clay in the potter’s hand, so are you in My hand, O house of Israel’” (Jeremiah 18:6 LSB).
Israel, it would seem, is the clay.
The kingdom of God appears during this period: when the iron and clay––Rome and Israel—are making an unsuccessful attempt at mixing. This kingdom is like a stone that strikes the image on its feet, smashing it, then grinding it to powder, then itself growing to fill the whole earth.
When Did the Kingdom of God Come?
The time when Israel and Rome were attempting to mix together was in the first century AD. We read statements like these:
“Now Herod and Pilate became friends with one another that very day; for before they had been enemies with each other” (Luke 23:12 LSB).
“For truly in this city there were gathered together against Your holy Servant Jesus, whom You anointed, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, along with the Gentiles and the peoples of Israel” (Acts 4:27 LSB).
This was the unholy alliance to end all unholy alliances. It was a time when Jewish priests shouted “We have no king but Caesar” (Jn 19:15), when Roman officials were marrying Jewish princesses like they were going out of fashion (see Acts 24:24).
It was into this first century AD that Christ came, teaching this:
“The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand; repent and believe in the gospel” (Mark 1:15 LSB).
The kingdom of God was “at hand” then: in AD 30. After this, the New Testament continues to affirm that the kingdom of God had arrived in the first century.
- Matthew 12:28––This is a straightforward if-then condition. “If I cast out demons by the Spirit of God, then the kingdom of God has come upon you.” Since Jesus did cast out demons by the Spirit of God, it follows that the kingdom of God had come upon them.
- Matthew 13:31 etc.––Christ repeatedly says “the kingdom is like [insert metaphor]”. Parables like the mustard seed favour the view that the kingdom began small and has been growing ever since.
- Matthew 16:28––There were some living in the first century who would not taste death until they saw the Son of Man coming in His kingdom.
- Luke 17:20-21––Jesus says the kingdom of God was already in their midst. They hadn’t seen it come because they were on the lookout for flashy “signs to be observed.”
- Matthew 23:13––People were already entering the kingdom of heaven.
- Acts 2:25-36––Jesus had already been made Lord and Christ (i.e., King) in fulfilment of the promises to David.
- Colossians 1:13––Believers have already been transferred into the kingdom of Christ.
- Romans 14:17––Paul describes the kingdom of God as “righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit.” The point of this statement is to change present-day behaviour to conform to a present-day kingdom.
- 1 Corinthians 4:20––The kingdom of God currently consists of power.
- Hebrews 12:22-28––We have already come to Mount Zion, and to the city of the living God. More than this, we are currently receiving a kingdom.
- Revelation 1:6––John says we are already a kingdom.
- Revelation 1:9––John says he is currently partaking in the kingdom.
This is an immodestly large dump of evidence, but a necessary one. The idea of a kingdom of God completely inexistent before the Second Coming must be shown to be utterly antithetical to New Testament doctrine.
Christ the Stone
The imagery of a stone capable of breaking in pieces is employed by Christ in the New Testament:
“Jesus said to them, ‘Did you never read in the Scriptures,
The stone which the builders rejected,
This became the chief corner stone;
This came about from the Lord,
And it is marvelous in our eyes’?
Therefore I say to you, the kingdom of God will be taken away from you and given to a nation, producing the fruit of it. And he who falls on this stone will be broken to pieces; but on whomever it falls, it will scatter him like dust” (Matthew 21:42-44 LSB).
What appears to be happening in these verses is a conflation of Jesus and ‘the kingdom of God.’ In a sense, they are identical, for those who enter Christ enter the kingdom (cp. Col. 1:13). A similar thing happens in Luke 17:20-21—the kingdom of God was in their midst in the person of Jesus. Luke 21:31 talks of the kingdom of God being near while the parallel prophecies speak of Jesus Himself coming in judgment.
Christadelphians have, at times, noticed this connection with a sense of relief, seeing it as a rationale for denying the coming of the kingdom in the first century. It was present in a sense, they say, but only in the person of Jesus. Note, however, that redefining 'the kingdom’ cannot solve this problem. However you define it (whether as Jesus Himself, or something else), the gospels are insistent that it had come.
Jesus—the stone—was the nucleus from which the kingdom of God would grow into a mountain that fills the earth. A similar motif is described in the parable of the mustard seed.
“The kingdom of heaven is like a mustard seed, which a man took and sowed in his field; and this is the smallest of all seeds, but when it is fully grown, it is the largest of the garden plants and becomes a tree, so that the birds of the air come and nest in its branches” (Matthew 13:31-32 LSB).
Pushing This Into the Corners
If Christ was the stone, the nucleus of the kingdom, when did He strike Nebuchadnezzar’s image?
This is the most common Christadelphian objection to the view that the kingdom of God arrived in the first century. Daniel describes this arrival as rather cataclysmic and striking, yet Christ’s First Coming was characterised by statements such as “a crushed reed He will not break and a faintly burning wick He will not extinguish” (Isa. 42:3).
What punctiliar moment of first century history could answer this moment in Nebuchadnezzars prophetic dream?
“You continued looking until a stone was cut out without hands, and it struck the image on its feet of iron and clay and crushed them” (Daniel 2:34 LSB).
Where was the image struck? On the feet. That is, a small part of the iron (Rome), and the clay (Israel). We are looking, therefore, for a cataclysmic moment that removed the nation of Israel and issued judgment on Rome.
In Matthew 24, Christ Himself prophesied of such a moment that would happen within a generation of His ministry (parallel: Mark 13, Luke 21). Though Rome itself was the instrument of judgment that utterly destroyed the Jewish nation, it did not escape judgment itself. Historically, Rome was plunged into civil war during the Year of the Four Emperors (AD 69), when successive claimants fought for the imperial throne following the collapse of the Julio-Claudian dynasty in AD 68, bringing political upheaval, bloodshed, and widespread instability.
Of course, the Roman Empire would continue to exist for many years to come. This is because the kingdom of God does not conquer the same way other empires do. Just as Daniel said “the wind carried them away so that no trace of them was found”, Christ taught the following when describing the work of the Holy Spirit:
“The wind blows where it wishes and you hear its sound, but do not know where it comes from and where it is going; so is everyone who is born of the Spirit” (John 3:8 LSB).
The kingdom of God is like leaven in a loaf, working from the inside out (Mt. 13:33). Thus, whereas the empires of Babylon, Medo-persia and Greece fell relatively quickly—or extremely quickly in some cases—Rome seemed to rot and collapse over over an inordinate length of time. Its fall is consistent with Daniel’s imagery of being ground to powder.
When Will the Kingdom of God Look Like Psalm 72?
The kingdom of God being established in the first century does not mean that Psalm 72, and other texts like it, would immediately be a reality. The world is still full of afflictions and Christ’s enemies do not yet lick the dust.
But remember that the apostles were looking for the restored kingdom of Israel (Acts 1:6), and Israel’s kingdom did not come all at once, but “little by little.”
“I will not drive them out before you in a single year, lest the land become desolate and the beasts of the field become too numerous for you. I will drive them out before you little by little, until you become fruitful and take the land as an inheritance” (Exodus 23:29-30 LSB, emphasis added).
This is why the remainder of Acts presents the kingdom of Christ as a repeat, only better, of the kingdom of Israel. The law was given in Exodus 19; the gospel was given in Acts 2. Fire descended upon the mountain in Exodus 19; fire descended upon the apostles in Acts 2. 3000 were killed for rebellion in Exodus 32; 3000 were baptised in belief in Acts 2. Israel went forth to conquer Canaan in the books of Joshua and Judges; the church goes out to conquer the whole world, beginning in Acts.
Psalm 72, and others like it, presents a very Solomon-esque picture; yet Israel did not reach the age of Solomon until it had gone through many years of wars and hardship. By the same token, do not expect the New Covenant kingdom to reached the Solomon-era in a mere millennia or two.
God promised his faithfulness “to thousands of generations” and the world has been around for, at most, about two hundred.
In other words, we’re just getting started.
If this annoys you because you wanted to experience Psalm 72 in your lifetime, then there are two points worth raising. First, the fact that Moses never experienced the promised land in his lifetime is not proof that Israel’s kingdom didn’t exist in his lifetime. Second, there is always the Second Coming and the resurrection.
What About the Second Coming?
Like every orthodox Christian in history, I believe in the Second Coming and the Final Resurrection with all my heart.
Aside from all doctrinal squabbles, the one thing on which every creed, confession, and catechism throughout history has agreed is that Christ will physically return to the earth and that the dead will be physically raised from the dust of the earth. You cannot read Scripture honestly and conclude otherwise.
And rest assured that the world will be in an even better state than Psalm 72 describes. Once God has released earth from its curse of death (see Romans 8), there will be no more afflicted for whom to render judgment (cp. Psa. 72:2).
It’s going to be great.
Appendix: The Ten Toes
Christadelphians are very detail-oriented, and many will want to know what the ten toes of the image refer to.
I would first like to point out that the number “ten” is not mentioned in Daniel 2, and so it is evidently not important to that particular prophecy.
Second, remember that Christadelphians themselves cannot agree whether it refers to the ten barbarian tribes that succeeded the Roman Empire, or the ten nations of modern Europe.
Third, note that there were actually more than ten barbarian tribes, and there are currently over twenty nations in the European Union.
If we seek a Biblical solution, however, what we find is that the New Testament records ten significant Jewish and Roman leaders from the period in question, all of whom fought against the establishment of the Kingdom of God through Christ and his apostles:
- Herod the Great, who came to power with Roman support, and tried to kill Christ (Matthew 2).
- Herod Antipas, who killed John the Baptist and conspired with Pilate to kill Christ (Matthew 14, Luke 23).
- Pontius Pilate, who conspired with Herod to kill Christ (Matthew 27).
- Caiaphas the High Priest, who led the Jewish trial against Christ, and “delivered him to Pontius Pilate” (Matthew 26-27).
- Annas the High Priest, who was the “first” instigator of the trial and crucifixion of Jesus, and a key persecutor of the apostles (John 18, Acts 4).
- Herod Agrippa I, who killed James, imprisoned Peter, and was eaten by worms (Acts 12).
- Governor Felix, who married Drusilla the wife of Herod, and oversaw Paul’s imprisonment (Acts 24).
- Governor Festus, who succeeded Felix and caused Paul to stand trial (Acts 25).
- Herod Agrippa II, who oversaw the trial of Paul at Jerusalem (Acts 25).
- Nero Caesar, to whom Paul appealed, and by whom he was killed (mentioned Acts 25ff).
These are ten rulers, each of them either iron or clay. I will not stake the validity of my interpretation on the exact enumeration of these rulers, but it is far more convincing than the Christadelphian alternative.
Image © Revelation TV / FreeBibleimages.org, licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.
Get in touch
Thoughts or questions?
Send a private note about this piece, music lessons, software, or writing.